Spamalot

Are some of the Spam Cures Worse than the Disease?

That the headline of the lead story in the latest WinXPnews. They go on to mention the large number of reader emails they get and how few of them they actually have time to personally answer, and how, when they do take time to answer, they are hit with the “Go to this website and be verified to send an email to this address”. Inevitably, they don’t do it. I don’t do it either. Here’s the thing, if you use one of these services, and you send an addess to a writer, or even just an every day blogger like myself, at least have the decency to whitelist my address from the get-go if you expect a response from me! Don’t write me, expecting a response, and then make me jump through hoops to send it to you! I won’t.

But this is just one example where some anti-spam measures have simply gone too far. Believe me, I know all about the problems created by junk email, I spend part of every day dealing with the incoming junk and tweaking our Postini settings and redirects to try and get rid of as much junk as possible without losing good email in the process. On the other hand, I work for a membership organization that sends email newsletter to it’s members. (People who have asked to get our email!) I see both sides of the problem. I see the ton of junk email coming in and I see the number of people who never get our emails because they are bulk-mailed and their email systems assume it must be spam. Simply adding a tax to that newsletter means we probably stop sending it. How is that beneficial? How is allowing people who disagree or compete with us the right to complain about spam and get us blacklisted helping matters? How is making it harder to communicate using email helping things at all?

Not that I’m saying we shouldn’t have these tools. I have them, I use them and I enjoy them. But, if you’re going to have these tools, make them work for you, not against you and the people you’re trying to communicate with. If your ultimate desire is to only get email that you want, at least take the time to make sure your anti-spam measures aren’t blocking that email, or making it too difficult to send you email. Eventually, if it’s too difficult, people will stop sending you email and you will end up getting no value from your email account at all.

Similar Posts

  • Bagle

    I’ve been keeping an eye on our Postini re-routed virus emails and waiting for a story like this one to hit Bloglines. I knew it couldn’t just be us! Follow these topics: Uncategorized

  • The dirty details

    While still trying to keep a bit of mystery about where I currently work, and where I’m going to be working, there are a few things that I find very interesting about my upcoming job-switch that I want to share and discuss. Mostly, I’m interested in how much of my experience can be extrapolated out…

  • Yesterday..

    Yesterday afternoon, the company that acts as our ISP at work disappeared from the face of the earth. OK not really, but it seemed that way for all intents and purposes. An electrical transformer blew somewhere near their building and their backup systems only had about an hour of life. I watched in horror as…

  • Not to be confused with Noogie

    I got an email over the weekend from Jacob Rheuban, one of the founders of a new news aggregation site called Newgie. The site promises to be a smarter news portal and RSS feed directory. From their press release: Newgie co-founders Jason Windebank (29) and Jacob Rheuban (29) began work on the new product six months ago…

  • TCP/IP stack update

    I spent a late night over the weekend trying to fix the problem with Angela’s current PC. Basically what happened is that back when we had the cable modem installed and there was a problem with it, the Roadrunner tech support folks, rather than believing that the problem was with their modem, had me uninstall…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post's permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post's URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)