Looks like the growing pains for the Old Reader were simply too much, and they are taking the service private.
I know Feedly seemed to be the popular choice, but it just doesn’t work for how I deal with RSS Feeds. I like to be able to read my feeds in a web browser, across any device I might be using, multiple computers, iOS devices, etc. I don’t want apps, or browser extensions, I want a website I can get to from anywhere. That’s what I enjoy about the Old Reader, hopefully someone will take them up on the offer to take over the project.
In the mean time, any other suggestions?